Lederer, David (2011) The Myth of the All-Destructive War: Afterthoughts on German Suffering, 1618–1648*. German History, 29 (3). pp. 380-403. ISSN 0266-3554

Preview

Download (2MB) | Preview

Abstract

Like perhaps no other military struggle in German history, the Thirty Years War exemplifies a conflagration largely defined by immense suffering. It offers an optimal testcase for the analysis of suffering as an emotional category by historians. In the twentieth century, some (such as Dame C.V. Wedgewood or the SS officer Günther Franz) employed a political frame of reference to more recent events in German history. One of the inadequacies of this interpretative framework is its tendency to moralize and over-simplify the roles of victims and perpetrators. In fact, we now recognize that most suffering during the Thirty Years War related only indirectly to military conflict, resulting instead from economic disaster, famine and disease. As a direct outcome of the war, rape poignantly illustrates methodological difficulties facing historians of suffering, given the patriarchal character of seventeenth-century society. The present historiography overcomes a variety of obstacles through micro-historic methods employing so-called ego-documents and Selbstzeugnisse. Theoretically, William Reddy’s exploration of hyperbolic sentimentality during the French Revolution may offer us a better analytical framework for understanding suffering during the Thirty Years War. In our case, a hyperbolic sensitivity to suffering shared by victims and non-victims alike contributed to the cessation of hostilities at Münster/Osnabrück and enshrined principles of sovereignty and religious tolerance in the Western political vocabulary. Thus elevated, the mechanisms of emotional suffering assume a central explanatory role in our understanding of the Thirty Years War.

Item Type:	Article
Keywords:	destruction of Magdeburg; Günther Franz; Dame C. V. Wedgewood; emotions (history of); ego-documents; rape;
Academic Unit:	Faculty of Arts,Celtic Studies and Philosophy > History
Item ID:	11484
Identification Number:	https://doi.org/10.1093/gerhis/ghr045
Depositing User:	David Lederer
Date Deposited:	29 Oct 2019 15:31
Journal or Publication Title:	German History
Publisher:	Oxford University Press (German History Society)
Refereed:	Yes
URI:	Publisher
Use Licence:	This item is available under a Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Licence (CC BY-NC-SA). Details of this licence are available here

Repository Staff Only(login required)

Item control page

Downloads

Origin of downloads