MURAL - Maynooth University Research Archive Library

    Why Our Next President May Keep His or Her Senate Seat: A Conjecture on the Constitution's Incompatibility Clause

    Tillman, Seth Barrett (2009) Why Our Next President May Keep His or Her Senate Seat: A Conjecture on the Constitution's Incompatibility Clause. Duke Journal of Constitutional Law & Public Policy, 4. pp. 107-141.

    This is the latest version of this item.

    [img] Download (310kB)
    Download (317kB) | Preview

    Share your research

    Twitter Facebook LinkedIn GooglePlus Email more...

    Add this article to your Mendeley library


    In a few months, We the People will go to the polls and elect the electors who will elect (or, at least, have an opportunity to elect) the next President of the United States. Short of an act of God or an act of war, it is more likely than not that the next President will be a sitting United States Senator. The expectation is that a Senator/President-elect resigns his or her legislative seat some time prior taking the presidential oath of office. It is widely believed in large and influential academic circles and among the educated public generally that the Constitution requires this result by expressly precluding joint simultaneous Legislative-Executive Branch office holding. I respectfully dissent. I believe the conventional view is mistaken as a matter of the original public meaning of the Constitution. Although the idea of a sitting Senator holding the office of President is somewhat counter-intuitive, this is one example of the dangers of unexamined intuitions. True, the Constitution does preclude joint Legislative Branch-Executive Branch service. But for incompatibility purposes, the President is not part of the Executive Branch; rather, the (elected) President presides over it, as opposed to (appointed) Executive Branch officers - which are under it. Therefore, a sitting Senator can keep his or her seat while serving as President. In addition to its primary point, that the President and Vice President are not subject to the Incompatibility Clause, this article makes a few other (subsidiary) points, including: (1) that "officers of the United States" is distinguishable from "officers under the United States" - the latter is slightly broader, and includes non-presiding legislative officers (along with contractors, low level employees, and special agents in irregular service to the federal government); (2) neither "officers of the United States" nor "officers under the United States" include the President or Vice President; (3) the Ineligibility Clause (a/k/a the Emoluments Clause) prevents members of Congress from being appointed to office (per Article I, Section 6, Clause 2), but does not prevent members from being elected to the Presidency or Vice Presidency or to Congress; (4) Senatorial disqualification following impeachment only extends to appointed office, not elected office (member of Congress, President, or Vice President - except possibly where the Vice President is appointed per the Twenty Fifth Amendment); (5) offices created per the Appointments Clause can only be created by statute, not by treaty; (6) the Foreign Emoluments Clause does not apply to the President and Vice President (see Article I, Section 9, Clause 8); (7) a President and Vice President even if running for re-election are eligible to serve as an elector under the Elector Incompatibility Clause (see Article II, Section 1, Clause 2); (8) legislative officer succession poses no constitutional difficulties per the Succession Clause; (9) the President is only subject to the Article II oath, but not the Article VI oath; and (10) the President and Vice President are holders of a "public trust" per the Article VI Religious Test Clause.

    Item Type: Article
    Keywords: President; Senator; Incompatibility;
    Academic Unit: Faculty of Social Sciences > Law
    Item ID: 4748
    Depositing User: Seth Tillman
    Date Deposited: 03 Feb 2014 14:23
    Journal or Publication Title: Duke Journal of Constitutional Law & Public Policy
    Publisher: Duke University School of Law
    Refereed: No
      Use Licence: This item is available under a Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Licence (CC BY-NC-SA). Details of this licence are available here

      Available Versions of this Item

      Repository Staff Only(login required)

      View Item Item control page


      Downloads per month over past year

      Origin of downloads