Whelan, Nuala (2018) Evaluating the effectiveness and implementation of new employment enhancement programmes in an Irish context: A focus on well-being and employability. PhD thesis, National University of Ireland Maynooth.
Preview
NualaWhelanThesis.pdf
Download (3MB) | Preview
Abstract
Unemployment is a persistent global
problem which has attracted considerable interest
in recent years from governments, policy makers, researchers and practitioners.
During
the last three decades or so, there has been a significant shift in international labour
market policy (and its impleme
ntation) toward activation and active labour market
policy to help the unemployed progress more quickly into employment. In Ireland,
policy changes in this direction have been more recent, with the implementation of the
new Pathways to Work policy (PTWP).
However, long
-
term unemployment (LTU)
remains high and more work is needed, both nationally and internationally, to identify
how best to intervene effectively and appropriately with this vulnerable group.
This research
comprised three separate
,
inter
-
rela
ted studies
,
designed to: (1) critically
examine the implementation and perceived effectiveness of the PTWP in Ireland; (2)
evaluate the effectiveness of a new high support intervention
(
when compared to
services as usual
)
in terms of
its
impact on psychol
ogical well
-
being and related
psychosocial factors which influence employability; and (3) conduct a small
-
scale
process evaluation to explore the implementation aspects and mechanisms underpinning
the new intervention and to draw some comparisons, in paral
lel, with routine PTWP
services.
The three studies were conducted within a
mixed
-
methods pragmatic framework and
comprised: (1)
an exploration of the perceptions and views of the PTWP amongst a
range of stakeholders (
N
=21) using semi
-
structured interviews
and
analysed using a
constructivist grounded theory approach; (2) a single
-
centre randomised controlled trial
(RCT) with a sample of LTU clients (
N
=149) who were followed up immediately post
-
intervention and six months
later to assess changes in primary and secondary outcomes
and (3) a process evaluation using both semi
-
structured interviews (n = 6) and focus
groups (n = 9) and analysed using standard thematic analysis.
Study One identified three overarching themes re
levant to the effectiveness of the
PTWP including: (1) ‘the reform agenda’; (2) ‘depersonalisation’: and, (3) the missing
‘how to’ of implementation. Study Two indicated high levels of psychological distress
at baseline, as well as findings to suggest that
both the intervention and services
-
as
-
usual had led to improvements over time in well
-
being and employability, albeit with a
number of more positive effects observed amongst the men who took part in the
intervention. The process evaluation revealed three
important themes with regard to
implementation aspects of the intervention including the important role of: (1) the
practitioner
-
client relationship; (2) the service setting; and (3) the skill sets of
practitioners.
This study is the first to examine the
PTWP with regard to psychological well
-
being and
employability outcomes for the LTU. It provides
support for detailing the ‘how to’ of
implementation, emphasising the potential added value of well
-
designed interventions
both in terms of mental health and w
ell
-
being outcomes, and career progression. The
findings suggest that practitioners, employment services, policy makers and other
stakeholders, should recognise the important role of careful, appropriate, and quality
-
focused ALMP interventions in terms of
promoting increased and sustainable
employability, positive mental
-
health, and improved quality of life for our most
vulnerable and disadvantaged job seekers.
Item Type: | Thesis (PhD) |
---|---|
Keywords: | Evaluating; effectiveness; implementation; employment enhancement programmes; Irish context; focus; well-being; employability; |
Academic Unit: | Faculty of Science and Engineering > Psychology |
Item ID: | 9569 |
Depositing User: | IR eTheses |
Date Deposited: | 19 Jun 2018 15:14 |
Funders: | Irish Research Council |
URI: | https://mural.maynoothuniversity.ie/id/eprint/9569 |
Use Licence: | This item is available under a Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Licence (CC BY-NC-SA). Details of this licence are available here |
Repository Staff Only (login required)
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year