Rooney, Niamh (2025) Who Knows? An exploration of knowledge democracy in community led development practice in rural Zambia. PhD thesis, National University of Ireland, Maynooth.
Preview
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial Share Alike.
Download (6MB) | Preview
Abstract
Current debates on development practice call for social justice through decolonisation,
localisation and shifting power to the grassroots. This research contributes to these
debates, challenging widely held notions of deficiency in development discourse and
practice through a critical examination of development practice in two rural communities
in Zambia, with a view to exploring their collective experience of knowledge democracy in
community led development practice. Informed by reflexive and critical theory
philosophies, the research specifically explores processes of knowledge production and
consumption, and the nature of collective participation, decision-making and
empowerment in community philanthropy and community-led development practice in
these communities. This research specifically recognises and explores the critical role of
collective learning, education and knowledge in achieving the social justice on which a
thriving global community depends.
The participatory approach and critical ethnographic intent reflect a commitment to issues
of social justice and equality which are central to knowledge democracy. This qualitative
research engaged with residents of two rural communities, Nyankanga and Kaminembe in
Zambia, and with ZGF, a local civil society organisation, through group discussion, semistructured
interview, observation and critical reflexive practice. We adopted a co-creative
approach which recognises community members as citizen knowers, decision makers and
knowledge producers, counter to deficit models of development and extractive research
processes.
Findings reveal evidence of a locally initiated and led community philanthropy model of
development drawing from diverse local collective knowledge and assets. Decisions and
agendas are shaped collectively, with strong participation and ownership, despite some
experiences of exclusion at the margins. Consistent attention to power dynamics and the
creation of inclusive enabling spaces are essential. Solidarity relations of mutuality,
partnership and long-term commitment foster essential community confidence and trust
and reinforce a truly community-driven approach.
This empirical evidence further justifies a change from hierarchical and deficit-based models
of development research, education and practice to grounded asset-based models and
approaches, such as community philanthropy, which recognise and value capability rather
than vulnerability. Inclusion and meaningful participation which values and supports local
knowledge, capacity and agency in community-led development is key. The importance of
solidarity rather than charity relations is amplified, emphasising a need for continuity and
long-term commitment which is not tied to funding cycles. Finally, a commitment to
transformative rather than technical approaches to localisation in practice is advocated.
In conclusion, this study contributes to the fields of epistemic justice, knowledge
democracy, development studies and transformative education, emphasising the value and
worth inherent in diverse ontologies and epistemologies, and their imperative to social
justice when integrated with inclusive and truly locally led development. This research
proposes a manifesto for knowledge democracy for citizens, educators, researchers, policy
makers, and development workers to advance just development and social change.
| Item Type: | Thesis (PhD) |
|---|---|
| Keywords: | Who knows; knowledge democracy; community led; development practice; Zambia; |
| Academic Unit: | Faculty of Social Sciences > Adult and Community Education |
| Item ID: | 21949 |
| Depositing User: | IR eTheses |
| Date Deposited: | 05 Oct 2026 15:25 |
| Use Licence: | This item is available under a Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Licence (CC BY-NC-SA). Details of this licence are available here |
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year
Share and Export
Share and Export