Pinter, Matjaz (2021) Transformations of Political Consciousness in the Process of State Formation in Nepal. PhD thesis, National University of Ireland Maynooth.
Preview
PhD Thesis Matjaz Pinter.pdf
Download (2MB) | Preview
Abstract
This thesis builds on an ethnographic study of revolutionary action in rural Nepal by
conceptually grounding it in political, economic and historical analyses of capitalist
development and state formation. Nepal’s hilly periphery has become an important
region, where systemic change and the rise of political movements make it necessary to
understand the inter-relation between broader structures of power and local cultural
meanings of resistance. The recent political history of Nepal has seen the interplay
between these forces through the rise of peasant politics that culminated in Maoist
politics. This movement process, politically marked by a 10-year long People’s War, has
led to the establishment of a federal republic and reshaped the socio-political landscape
of rural Nepal.
The thesis draws on long-term fieldwork engagement in the former Maoist base area in
Mid-Western Nepal. Through participant observation, interviews, life stories and
discourse analysis, the thesis explores the transformations of political consciousness in
rural Nepal. The first part of the thesis focuses on the ‘conditional element of class’,
through which I explore unifying and pluralizing tendencies of capitalist modernity. By
engaging with the topics of modernity, development, state-formation, and the theory of
uneven and combined development, chapters 3-7 explore the background of the peasant
movement process that is grounded in Nepal's integration into the global capitalist
economy.
The second part of the thesis focuses on the ‘potential element of class’ and the post-
revolutionary context of the Maoist insurgency by ethnographically studying the Maoist
movement process in Kham Magar villages. The multi-layered analysis of the uneven
development of revolutionary action digs deeper into the political process of the People’s
War to show how the Maoists created their discourse of resistance. I follow these
developments that overgrew the Maoist framing process and small scale organizing to the
larger political-ideological institutions that established the Maoist base area. The history
of Maoist rule in the village of Maikot shows that in the former base area, the Maoists
organised the peasant’s experience into a thickly interwoven world of ‘subaltern
counterpublics’. Although the Maoist movement has seen its decline, I argue that to
understand the process of social transformation in rural Nepal, we should investigate the
constantly changing elements of the subaltern experience. I explore this through the life
stories of former Maoist combatants that map the rough coordinates of the post-
revolutionary common sense. This topic is also addressed in the doctoral ethnographic
film Taking on the Storm (2021), a filmic exploration of post-revolutionary common
sense in the former Maoist base area. Maikot’s post-revolutionary context is further
explored by analyzing the yarsagumba economy, an ethnographic narrative that explores
the peasants’ increased dependency on this lucrative commodity chain. In the last chapter
entitled Mushroom at the Top of the World (accompanied by a film with the same title),
I show how the yarsagumba economy has created a hybrid form of subsumption,
reflecting the contingency and unevenness of capitalist development in rural Nepal. I
argue that the post-revolutionary situation in Rukum has increased the integration of
peasant lives into dependent precarious livelihoods concealed by politics of autonomy.
This has created a situation in which class struggle increases the power of rural elites over
the resource-dependent peasantry. Maikot’s ethnographic example brings us to a
conceptualisation of peasant politics and capitalist development, where the potential
elements of class strengthen the power of the rural elites, creating a form of passive
revolution.
Item Type: | Thesis (PhD) |
---|---|
Keywords: | Transformations; Political Consciousness; State Formation; Nepal; |
Academic Unit: | Faculty of Social Sciences > Anthropology |
Item ID: | 16748 |
Depositing User: | IR eTheses |
Date Deposited: | 28 Nov 2022 12:27 |
URI: | https://mural.maynoothuniversity.ie/id/eprint/16748 |
Use Licence: | This item is available under a Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Licence (CC BY-NC-SA). Details of this licence are available here |
Repository Staff Only (login required)
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year