Szczepan, Barbara (2024) The Impact of Crime Media on Peoples’ Perceptions of Crime, Perpetrators and Victims. Masters thesis, National University of Ireland Maynooth.
Preview
Barbara Szczepan.pdf
Download (629kB) | Preview
Abstract
This dissertation aims to analyse the potential negative impacts of crime-related media on
viewers’ perceptions about crime, perpetrators, and victims. It will be completed using
desk-based research as this is the most fitting and most practical method to answer the
research question. Using desk-based research allows me to compare and contrast various
perspectives on the same topic which will allow me to identify trends and patterns that
will allow me to answer my research question.
To conduct research for this dissertation I used Google Scholar, Scopus and EBSOhost
as my main sources of literature. Initial searches of “crime media” found around 3 million
results so I had to be more specific. Some of the search terms I used to utilise this search
engine and database more efficiently included: “crime media AND ethics” (approx. 1.86
million results), “crime media AND fear” (approx. 1.7 million results), “crime media
AND perpetrators” (approx. 270,000 results), “crime media AND police” (approx. 1.95
million results), “crime media AND race OR ethnicity” (approx. 870, 000), and “media
AND ideal victims” (approx. 440,000 results). Where appropriate, I also used both the
American English and UK English spellings of certain words (such as ‘sensationalization’
and ‘sensationalisation’, or ‘racialisation’ and ‘racialization’) to maximise the efficiency of
my searches.
Additionally, for the purposes of this dissertation I used some inclusion and
exclusion criteria to narrow down my searches to best fit my research question. I included
literature related to both fictional and non-fictional crime-related media; and media from
various sources, including television, newspapers, and true crime podcasts and
documentaries. When searching for literature I mainly limited myself to sources that were
written within the last four decades. I also limited myself to literature written in English.
While reviewing the existing literature I gathered to help me answer my research
question, I highlighted and took a note of the main findings of each relevant paper. This
allowed me to observe and keep track of common themes that emerge from the literature
in relation to this topic. These included: sensationalism in relation to ethics; biased
reporting; selective reporting that it at odds with official crime statistics; stereotyping; impacts related to police; impacts related to fear; differential treatment of minorities; and
typifying legitimate victims. Biased reporting involved either the over-representation or
underrepresentation of certain groups (Greer, 2007; Jewkes, 2015). Selective reporting
involved the overrepresentation of certain types of crimes (Jewkes, 2015; Grosholz &
Kubrin, 2007; Chermak, 1998; Greer, 2007), and victims and offenders (Grosholz &
Kubrin, 2007); as well as a focus on newsworthiness to create stories most appealing to
viewers (Dmitrieva, 2017; Greer, 2007). Stereotyping referred to stereotyping who
criminals are (including racial stereotyping and the racialisation of crime (Colburn &
Melander, 2018; Monk et al., 2007; Keating, 2002)) as well as stereotyping who victims
are (Christie, 1986; Dukes & Gaither, 2017). Impacts relating to police involved more
negative perceptions of police (Choi et al., 2020; Long, 2021); the impact of media on
perceptions of police efficiency (Dowler, 2002) and legitimacy (Jewkes, 2015); and the
link of perceptions of police to fear of crime (Choi et al., 2020). Impacts on fear of crime
examined the extent to which this occurs (Greer, 2007; Grabe & Drew, 2007; Choi et al.,
2020; Keating, 2002; Heath & Gilbert, 1996; Jewkes, 2015), including differences across
racial/ethnic groups (Callanan, 2012; Dowler, 2002). It also examined whether media
influences who one ‘should’ fear. Differential treatment of minorities examined the
overrepresentation of minorities as offenders (Callanan, 2012; Colburn & Melander,
2018), as well as minority victims and offenders being treated or portrayed differently and
more negatively (Dixon & Linz, 2002; Brennan & Vandenberg, 2009; Smiley & Fakunle,
2016; Long, 2021; Slakoff, 2018). The typification of legitimate victims focused on the
perpetuation of Nils Christie’s (1986) construct of ‘ideal victims’ in media (Long, 2021;
Greer, 2007), and how legitimate and illegitimate victims are treated differently (Slakoff,
2018; Lewis & Hamilton, 2021; DiBennardo, 2018). These themes will be further
elaborated on and explored throughout this dissertation.
Item Type: | Thesis (Masters) |
---|---|
Additional Information: | A dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of MA in Comparative Criminology and Criminal Justice. |
Keywords: | impact; crime media; peoples perceptions; crime; perpetrators; victims; Comparative Criminology and Criminal Justice; |
Academic Unit: | Faculty of Social Sciences > Law |
Item ID: | 19044 |
Depositing User: | IR eTheses |
Date Deposited: | 16 Oct 2024 10:52 |
URI: | https://mural.maynoothuniversity.ie/id/eprint/19044 |
Use Licence: | This item is available under a Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Licence (CC BY-NC-SA). Details of this licence are available here |
Repository Staff Only (login required)
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year