Doyle, Patricia (2009) A Sociological Study of Addiction: Power and Social Change from the "rock bottom up". PhD thesis, National University of Ireland Maynooth.
PDF
p_doyle_thesis.pdf
Download (1MB)
p_doyle_thesis.pdf
Download (1MB)
Abstract
In this study the subject of addiction/recovery is used to ‘test’ the conceptual ideas of
Margaret Archer (1996) and Thomas Smith (1995). Both are systems theorists’ and both
engage in cause and effect analysis. As they hold contrasting views on how personal and
cultural change takes place this study is an attempt to establish the direction of causal
influence on social change as it applies to the history of addiction/recovery from each
author’s perspective. By firstly examining the history of ideas (cultural system) from a
critical realist perspective followed by an exploration of how the recovering community
came to believe these ideas in the first place we are given a glimpse of the external
(Archer,1996) and internal (Smith, 1995) constraints that the recovering community has
confronted over time. Archer is keen to address the varying degrees of freedom and
constraint agency confronts at both the cultural system and socio-cultural systems level
over time. From her perspective these external constraints (causal factors) have a direct
input into “the nature of, and conditions for, autonomy (and its relation to social
determination)” (Lukes quoted in Archer, 1996:93) and have a conditioning effect on “the
degrees of freedom within which power can be exercised” (Archer, 1996: 93-94). However
in this study by applying Smith’s reformulation of Parsons’ work (non equilibrium
functionalism) to the study of addiction/recovery we are also alerted to the varying degrees
of freedom and constraint that are experienced at the level of the human being over time
which also has implications for agentic possibility over time. Beginning at the level of
physiology and not the social system and by exploring what addiction/recovery and the
cultural system means and has meant to the recovering community we can identify the
internal constraints (causal factors) that also have a direct input into the nature of, and
conditions for, the autonomy of the recovering community over time. These factors also
have a causal effect on the degrees of freedom within which power can be exercised. The
study of addiction/recovery alerts us to the utility of incorporating Smith’s clinical concept
of self object transference (1995: 30) in our analysis. By acknowledging the strong forces
that are clearly at work in interaction (ibid: vii) we can identify a form of power that has
been neglected in addiction studies and ruled out of explanation in social theory. This
personal, sometimes hidden, not always conscious, embodied and emotional dimension to
emergent power impacts equally on the addicted and non-addicted population alike. A
theory of addiction becomes a theory of social change when we recognize that these
internal forces (causal factors) guide our behaviour as surely as any of the generative
mechanisms (causal factors) identified by Archer. Moreover by focusing on the meaning
that the cultural system holds for recovering people which may be extended to include the
population more generally we can see that in terms of the direction of causal influence on
personal and social change it is the subjective meanings that the cultural system holds for
people that is what sometimes gives it its causal effect.
Item Type: | Thesis (PhD) |
---|---|
Keywords: | Sociological Study of Addiction; Power and Social Change; |
Academic Unit: | Faculty of Social Sciences > Sociology |
Item ID: | 2262 |
Depositing User: | IR eTheses |
Date Deposited: | 19 Nov 2010 11:44 |
URI: | https://mural.maynoothuniversity.ie/id/eprint/2262 |
Use Licence: | This item is available under a Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike Licence (CC BY-NC-SA). Details of this licence are available here |
Repository Staff Only (login required)
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year